Solana Stake Reward Adjustment Proposal, What Impact on SOL Price?
Original Author: David Grider, Partner at FinalityCap
Translation: zhouzhou, BlockBeats
Editor's Note: This article discusses a proposal regarding the adjustment of Solana staking rewards. The proposal's arguments have encountered issues, particularly concerning the impact of high staking rewards on DeFi yields and the effect of inflation on selling pressure. David counters by suggesting that the relationship between staking rewards, network security, and market demand is closely intertwined, and that staking rewards should be determined by the market.
The following is the original content (slightly reorganized for readability):
I am very concerned about the inflation reduction proposal SIMD-0228 put forth for Solana, especially the current version proposed by TusharJain and kankanivishal from multicoincap, as well as MaxResnick1, particularly without addressing some critical risks and issues.

After listening to the latest Solana Validator Community Call, I believe that the arguments made for implementing this change have significant flaws.

Here is a summary of the arguments presented, which I will refute in detail in upcoming tweets:
1: High staking rewards are detrimental to DeFi yields
2: Inflation increases selling pressure and should be compared to network fees
3: High staking rewards reduce ETF demand
4: Staking rewards do not offer U.S. tax optimization as capital gains do
5: Higher staking rewards do not lead to a higher price
6: The staking formula will optimize the staking ratio, thus addressing security concerns (in my view, this is a critical security risk and a flawed approach)
Argument 1: A high staking rate is detrimental to DeFi yields.
Refutation 1: SOL staking is Solana's risk-free rate. Just as a higher risk-free rate on government bonds leads to an increase in rates on the credit curve, higher staking rewards will drive up DeFi rates and profits.

Point 2: Inflation has increased selling pressure, which should be compared to fees.
Rebuttal 2: This is not valid, just like unlocking does not necessarily bring selling pressure, whether to sell depends on the holder's choice. Validators can choose to restake their staking rewards. The impact of inflation on liquidity is smaller compared to other supply factors. Instead of comparing selling pressure to fees, it is better to compare it to fund flows. One can look at the Solana ETP fund flows as a measurable metric, but demand from funds and individuals is larger and more significant.

Point 3: High staking rewards have reduced the demand for ETFs.
Rebuttal 3: Just because someone has used this point to explain the softness in ETH ETF demand does not mean it applies to Solana as well. Look at many of Europe's SOL ETPs; they take the entire staking yield and do not charge fees, attracting significant inflows of funds (as mentioned above). Moreover, US ETFs are also nearing approval for staking, so in the long run, this point does not hold.

Point 4: Staking rewards are not as tax-optimized as capital gains.
Rebuttal 4: Solana is a globally decentralized network; we should not optimize solely for US tax policies as tax policies can change at any time. This is similar to how equity investors would overlook the impact of tax changes on stock valuation.
Point 5: Higher staking rewards will not lead to a higher price.
Rebuttal 5: Real-world evidence proves this point invalid. Just look at how traditional currencies are priced. The valuation of one currency against another is usually based on the interest rate differential. Higher rates typically lead to a stronger currency. Here is a chart showing the USD/JPY against the US 10-year Treasury and Japanese 10-year Government Bond yield differentials as an example.

Point 6: The staking formula will optimize the staking ratio, thus addressing security concerns.
Rebuttal 6: It also needs to optimize the number of validators and staking distribution. Running Solana validators is costly, and the number of validators has been decreasing.

Rebuttal 6 (Continued): An analysis that must be conducted in order to move forward safely with this proposal, but what I have not seen yet is:
Simulating how many of the currently active small validators would become unprofitable and drop out under the new proposal. This needs to be analyzed under different network activity and SOL price assumptions, especially in a bear market scenario considering a 80% drop in both MEV and base fees, as well as prices. Then, looking at the current Solana validator list, see how many current validators would become unprofitable and drop out under these scenarios.
We can discuss how many validators Solana needs. It may not need to artificially inflate to 100,000 like ETH, but we also do not want Solana to become a Cosmos chain with only 100 validators.
Additionally, because proponents have brought up the argument of U.S. tax implications to drive this proposal, we are also not sure what the SEC's decentralization test standards are, so it might be desirable to keep the validator count above 1,000 to keep SOL as a commodity.
In conclusion, unless someone has at least done this analysis, this proposal should not go through.
The proposal indeed raises the right question: how much inflation is needed? But before making a change, there are other questions we need to answer. I do agree that this number could be lower and should be more dynamic. Just as a company does not need to pay a fixed amount to suppliers or provide a fixed return to financiers, the market should determine this number, so I support this direction. We just need to slow down, do more work to understand its impact.
This could actually be a high-level approach to addressing this risk.

My sincere suggestion is, we should not assume and generalize its impact. Data analysis should be done, displaying all assumptions and data.
You may also like

Trump Says He Was Unaware of $500M UAE Investment in World Liberty Financial
Key Takeaways: US President Donald Trump denied knowledge of a $500 million UAE investment in World Liberty Financial.…

Crypto Industry and Banks at a Stalemate Over Stablecoin Yield Deal
Key Takeaways The White House has urged a compromise on stablecoin yields to progress Senate crypto legislation. Crypto…

Why Vitalik Buterin Sold Over 700 Ethereum (ETH) Despite Market Recovery
Key Takeaways Vitalik Buterin sold over 700 Ethereum not for market reasons but to finance long-term projects. The…

Binance Withdrawals Restored Following Temporary Disruption
Key Takeaways Binance faced technical difficulties affecting withdrawals, but services were quickly restored within 20 minutes. The disruption…

Asian Markets Stabilize as Bitcoin Trades Around $78K
Key Takeaways Bitcoin steadies at approximately $78,000 as Asian markets recover from recent volatility. Regional equities, including Japan’s…

Bitcoin Price Prediction: The Warsh Shock & The Stablecoin Summit—Is the Bull Case Dead?
Key Takeaways Kevin Warsh’s nomination as Federal Reserve Chair has caused a drop in liquidity for riskier assets,…

White House Continues to Negotiate Over Crypto Market Structure Bill
Key Takeaways The White House is pushing for a compromise on the contentious issue of stablecoin yields in…

Billionaire Michael Saylor’s Strategy Acquires $75M More Bitcoin – Is This a Bullish Sign?
Key Takeaways Michael Saylor’s Strategy has expanded its Bitcoin holdings by purchasing an additional 855 BTC for $75.3…

Polymarket Bettors Assign Over 70% Probability of Bitcoin Dropping Below $65K — Are They Correct?
Key Takeaways Polymarket users predict Bitcoin has a 71% chance of falling below $65,000 in 2026, reflecting market…

CFTC Regulatory Shift Could Unlock New Growth for Coinbase Prediction Markets
Key Takeaways Newly appointed CFTC Chair, Michael Selig, aims for a unified federal oversight approach for crypto-linked prediction…

We Hacked Perplexity AI to Predict the Price of XRP, Bitcoin, and Ethereum By the End of 2026
Key Takeaways Perplexity AI predicts XRP may soar to $8 by 2026, fueled by legal victories and supportive…

Current Crypto Price Predictions: An In-Depth Analysis of XRP, Dogecoin, and Shiba Inu
Key Takeaways XRP, Dogecoin, and Shiba Inu are experiencing significant price declines amid geopolitical uncertainties and general market…

Pepe Coin Forecast: Price Appears Dismal, Yet Savvy Investors Rally Behind the Scenes
Key Takeaways Pepe Coin has experienced significant price drops, yet indicators suggest it may soon bottom out, with…

BitMine Reports 4.285M ETH Holdings, Expands Staked Position With Massive Reward Outlook
Key Takeaways BitMine Immersion Technologies has reported significant crypto holdings valued at $10.7 billion. The company’s Ethereum holdings…

Crypto Exchanges’ Stock Plunge 60% as Trading Volumes Dwindle – Is the Decline Ending or Just Beginning?
Key Takeaways Trading volumes on major crypto exchanges have drastically fallen, with a nearly 90% drop from October…

Best Crypto to Acquire Now February 2 – XRP, Solana, Ethereum
Key Takeaways Recent market turmoil saw Bitcoin plunge dramatically, affecting all major cryptocurrencies. XRP, Solana, and Ethereum are…

Ethereum Price Prediction: Top ETH Bulls Face $7.6 Billion in Paper Losses as Price Drops Below $2,400
Key Takeaways Ethereum has faced a downturn, dropping 19% below $2,400, resulting in significant paper losses for major…

Shiba Inu Price Prediction: SHIB Just Crashed to a 3-Year Low – Is SHIB Heading Towards Zero?
Key Takeaways Shiba Inu has recently hit a significant low, experiencing a 15% drop that places it at…
Trump Says He Was Unaware of $500M UAE Investment in World Liberty Financial
Key Takeaways: US President Donald Trump denied knowledge of a $500 million UAE investment in World Liberty Financial.…
Crypto Industry and Banks at a Stalemate Over Stablecoin Yield Deal
Key Takeaways The White House has urged a compromise on stablecoin yields to progress Senate crypto legislation. Crypto…
Why Vitalik Buterin Sold Over 700 Ethereum (ETH) Despite Market Recovery
Key Takeaways Vitalik Buterin sold over 700 Ethereum not for market reasons but to finance long-term projects. The…
Binance Withdrawals Restored Following Temporary Disruption
Key Takeaways Binance faced technical difficulties affecting withdrawals, but services were quickly restored within 20 minutes. The disruption…
Asian Markets Stabilize as Bitcoin Trades Around $78K
Key Takeaways Bitcoin steadies at approximately $78,000 as Asian markets recover from recent volatility. Regional equities, including Japan’s…
Bitcoin Price Prediction: The Warsh Shock & The Stablecoin Summit—Is the Bull Case Dead?
Key Takeaways Kevin Warsh’s nomination as Federal Reserve Chair has caused a drop in liquidity for riskier assets,…